EEOC Releases Draft Guidance on National Origin Discrimination, and Requests Public Comment
June 3, 2016
The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”) issued proposed enforcement guidance on national origin discrimination on June 2, 2016.
Key Takeaways:
The EEOC guidance incorporates a wide array of topics related to national origin discrimination including intersectional discrimination, human trafficking, harassment, accent and fluency, national security requirements, and citizenship issues. In addition, the guidance also includes a “promising practices” section highlighting actions or programs to help employers reduce the risk of Title VII violations based on national origin. Although the EEOC has not included sweeping changes in re-interpreting Title VII, there are a number of areas where the agency is pushing the envelope to expand the scope of national origin coverage.
Additional Details:
When finalized, the guidance will replace Section 13 of the EEOC’s Compliance Manual, which was issued 14 years ago, in December 2002. It is somewhat surprising that the agency chose to update its guidance on national origin at this time, because there have been very few significant changes in this area of the law since the prior guidance issued. Additionally, the number of charges alleging national origin discrimination has remained steady during the 14-year-period. In 2002, 10.6 percent of EEOC charges alleged national origin discrimination. As of last year, that number rose a mere 0.1 percent to 10.7 percent.
The most significant aspects of the EEOC’s proposed guidance:
- Overlap and Intersectional Discrimination – The EEOC expects claims of national origin discrimination to be more likely to overlap with allegations of race, color or religious discrimination, resulting in charges alleging multiple bases of discrimination. The EEOC considers adverse treatment because an individual is a combination of two or more protected bases, i.e. an Asian woman to be ?intersectional discrimination” that should result in claims of national origin, race and sex discrimination.
- Human Trafficking – Title VII can apply to human trafficking cases if the employer’s conduct is directed at an individual or a group of individuals based upon national origin. The EEOC also indicates that egregious employer conduct that is typical in human trafficking cases will likely constitute unlawful harassment.
- Recruitment – If an employer’s current staff is ethnically or racially homogenous, the EEOC is more likely to view word of mouth recruitment and sending job posting only to ethnically or racially homogenous areas or audiences as having the purpose effect of excluding applicants based on national origin.
- Joint Employer – When a staffing firm and an employer have the right to control the means and manner of a worker’s employment they may be considered joint employers under Title VII regardless of whether they actually exercise that right to control the worker’s employment or have the statutory number of employees.
- Screening Based on Social Security Number – The practice of screening out new hires or candidates who cannot provide a Social Security number could run afoul of Title VII’s disparate impact theory if it disproportionately screens out work-authorized but newly-arrived immigrants and new lawful permanent residents of a certain ethnicity or national origin.
- Harassment Policies in Employees’ Native Spoken Language – In evaluating the effectiveness of the employer harassment policy for a Farragher-Ellerth affirmative defense, the EEOC will consider whether the complaint mechanism was accessible in the native languages spoken by employees if the employer knew of, or should have known of, the employees’ limited language capabilities.
- The Impact of the Guidance – Although EEOC Enforcement Guidance does not carry the same force of law that regulations establish, many courts are willing to provide deference to EEOC guidance and rulings based on the agency’s knowledge and expertise. The EEOC relies upon its Enforcement Guidance to direct its employees in charge investigations and related processing such as making cause determinations and considering litigation.
Follow Up Actions for Employers:
The public has until July 1, 2016 to provide input on the proposed guidance. The EEOC will consider the public’s comments before finalizing and releasing the guidance.
Employers should review the EEOC’s proposed guidance on national origin and consider whether their current policies and practices are in compliance.
Please contact FortneyScott if you have questions about the proposed National Origin Enforcement Guidance and how it may affect your business. For more information, contact Leslie Silverman, Esq., Shareholder at FortneyScott and former Vice Chair of the EEOC, or by telephone, 202-689-1204.
December 18, 2025 at noon EDT CLICK HERE to Register Join FortneyScott attorneys for a complimentary webinar on how employers should prepare for 2026 based on the significant changes in 2025. The Trump Administration begins 2026 with a quorum at the EEOC, new leadership at all the DOL agencies, and the likelihood that the NLRB quorum will be restored soon, so employers should expect aggressive action by all the workforce agencies. This session will provide critical insights into: What to expect from EEOC with its new quorum; An activated DOL, including the new Wage & Hour Division priorities, such as revisions to the Biden-era rules on white collar exemptions and joint employment; new Opinion Letters and compliance tools, how AI is being addressed, and expected developments; Whether OFCCP will survive in 2026, and changes affecting Federal contractors and grant recipients; and Practical steps employers should consider before 2026 begins. This is the final presentation in FortneyScott’s four-part Workplace Legal Compliance Webinar Series 2025, designed for in-house counsel, compliance professionals, HR leaders, and business executives. To register for FortneyScott’s Workplace Legal Compliance training series, please click here .
The longest US government shutdown has ended; the House will return to Washington and Congress will resume operations; the EEOC has a quorum and can fully operate; the leadership teams for all DOL agencies now are in place; the NLRB waits to learn the fate of its Members; and, the U.S. Supreme Court will be confronting its Emergency Rulings (the “shadow docket”) in merits rulings on the regular docket in several high stakes cases. Everyone in Washington, the US, and, indeed, the whole world is watching and trying to plan their next steps. Join the Employment Law Alliance (ELA) for an engaging and timely webinar where speakers will discuss what is likely to unfold regarding the workplace and beyond. They will offer practical guidance both for US companies and those that do business with the US .
November 20, 2025 at noon EDT CLICK HERE to Register Join FortneyScott attorneys for a timely webinar addressing the Trump Administration’s escalating enforcement efforts targeting “illegal DEI” practices among federal contractors, grant recipients, and higher education institutions. In recent months, the Administration has initiated certification demands, expanded DOJ investigations under the False Claims Act, and increased EEOC scrutiny under Title VII. This session will provide critical insights into: The latest developments in federal investigations and enforcement; DEI programs under legal challenge; and Practical steps employers—especially federal contractors and grant recipients—should take now to mitigate legal risk and ensure compliance with EEO laws. This is the third installment in FortneyScott’s four-part Workplace Legal Compliance Webinar Series, designed for in-house counsel, compliance professionals, HR leaders, and business executives. To register for FortneyScott’s Workplace Legal Compliance training series, please click here .
Understanding that everyone is going into Q4, which is the kickoff of your merit and compensation cycles, we want to support those compliance efforts. Join FortneyScott attorneys and our guest speaker, Rick Holt from Resolution Economics, on Thursday, October 23, 2025, at noon EDT for a discussion on strategies for reviewing compensation decisions under the governing legal standards and the Trump Administration’s enforcement priorities. We will focus on discussing: Changes in legal enforcements; Legal considerations for conducting pay analyses; Recommendations on refreshing analysis models; and, Remediation strategies.
On Tuesday, December 2, at 2pm EST , join attorneys from Novus Law Firm and FortneyScott and an I/O Psychologist from DCI as we discuss the scope of data being requested by the federal government and how to ensure that your institution is prepared. To register for this complimentary webinar, please CLICK HERE . Higher Education continues to be targeted by the Administration’s enforcement efforts to ensure compliance with federal anti-discrimination laws. Employment and admissions practices are subject to increased scrutiny by multiple federal agencies. For instance, both the Department of Justice (DOJ) and Health & Human Services (HHS) have issued Civil Investigation Demand (CID) letters requiring the submission of voluminous data and documents. These investigations pose significant risks, including potential civil and criminal lability, and the loss of federal contracts and grants. Additionally, the Department of Education (ED) has proposed major changes to the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) which, if implemented, would require institutions to report up to six years of detailed admissions data including applicant demographics and admissions criteria for undergraduate and graduate programs. Given this rapidly changing legal compliance landscape, higher education institutions should be prepared for government investigations that scrutinize wide-ranging practices, including those related to employment, admissions, and compensation. We will cover: Responding to federal agency investigations, which can include CIDs & scope of data production How to prepare for a potential investigation How the proposed IPED revisions may impact reporting burdens How federal agencies may use and share institute data Prospective data analytics that should be conducted
Understanding that everyone is going into Q4, which is the kickoff of your merit and compensation cycles, we want to support those compliance efforts. Join FortneyScott attorneys and our guest speaker, Rick Holt from Resolution Economics, on Thursday, October 23, 2025, at noon EDT for a discussion on strategies for reviewing compensation decisions under the governing legal standards and the Trump Administration’s enforcement priorities. We will focus on discussing: Changes in legal enforcements; Legal considerations for conducting pay analyses; Recommendations on refreshing analysis models; and, Remediation strategies. To register for FortneyScott’s Workplace Legal Compliance training series, please click here .
December 18, 2025 at noon EDT CLICK HERE to Register Join FortneyScott attorneys for a complimentary webinar on how employers should prepare for 2026 based on the significant changes in 2025. The Trump Administration begins 2026 with a quorum at the EEOC, new leadership at all the DOL agencies, and the likelihood that the NLRB quorum will be restored soon, so employers should expect aggressive action by all the workforce agencies. This session will provide critical insights into: What to expect from EEOC with its new quorum; An activated DOL, including the new Wage & Hour Division priorities, such as revisions to the Biden-era rules on white collar exemptions and joint employment; new Opinion Letters and compliance tools, how AI is being addressed, and expected developments; Whether OFCCP will survive in 2026, and changes affecting Federal contractors and grant recipients; and Practical steps employers should consider before 2026 begins. This is the final presentation in FortneyScott’s four-part Workplace Legal Compliance Webinar Series 2025, designed for in-house counsel, compliance professionals, HR leaders, and business executives. To register for FortneyScott’s Workplace Legal Compliance training series, please click here .
The longest US government shutdown has ended; the House will return to Washington and Congress will resume operations; the EEOC has a quorum and can fully operate; the leadership teams for all DOL agencies now are in place; the NLRB waits to learn the fate of its Members; and, the U.S. Supreme Court will be confronting its Emergency Rulings (the “shadow docket”) in merits rulings on the regular docket in several high stakes cases. Everyone in Washington, the US, and, indeed, the whole world is watching and trying to plan their next steps. Join the Employment Law Alliance (ELA) for an engaging and timely webinar where speakers will discuss what is likely to unfold regarding the workplace and beyond. They will offer practical guidance both for US companies and those that do business with the US .
November 20, 2025 at noon EDT CLICK HERE to Register Join FortneyScott attorneys for a timely webinar addressing the Trump Administration’s escalating enforcement efforts targeting “illegal DEI” practices among federal contractors, grant recipients, and higher education institutions. In recent months, the Administration has initiated certification demands, expanded DOJ investigations under the False Claims Act, and increased EEOC scrutiny under Title VII. This session will provide critical insights into: The latest developments in federal investigations and enforcement; DEI programs under legal challenge; and Practical steps employers—especially federal contractors and grant recipients—should take now to mitigate legal risk and ensure compliance with EEO laws. This is the third installment in FortneyScott’s four-part Workplace Legal Compliance Webinar Series, designed for in-house counsel, compliance professionals, HR leaders, and business executives. To register for FortneyScott’s Workplace Legal Compliance training series, please click here .
Understanding that everyone is going into Q4, which is the kickoff of your merit and compensation cycles, we want to support those compliance efforts. Join FortneyScott attorneys and our guest speaker, Rick Holt from Resolution Economics, on Thursday, October 23, 2025, at noon EDT for a discussion on strategies for reviewing compensation decisions under the governing legal standards and the Trump Administration’s enforcement priorities. We will focus on discussing: Changes in legal enforcements; Legal considerations for conducting pay analyses; Recommendations on refreshing analysis models; and, Remediation strategies.
On Tuesday, December 2, at 2pm EST , join attorneys from Novus Law Firm and FortneyScott and an I/O Psychologist from DCI as we discuss the scope of data being requested by the federal government and how to ensure that your institution is prepared. To register for this complimentary webinar, please CLICK HERE . Higher Education continues to be targeted by the Administration’s enforcement efforts to ensure compliance with federal anti-discrimination laws. Employment and admissions practices are subject to increased scrutiny by multiple federal agencies. For instance, both the Department of Justice (DOJ) and Health & Human Services (HHS) have issued Civil Investigation Demand (CID) letters requiring the submission of voluminous data and documents. These investigations pose significant risks, including potential civil and criminal lability, and the loss of federal contracts and grants. Additionally, the Department of Education (ED) has proposed major changes to the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) which, if implemented, would require institutions to report up to six years of detailed admissions data including applicant demographics and admissions criteria for undergraduate and graduate programs. Given this rapidly changing legal compliance landscape, higher education institutions should be prepared for government investigations that scrutinize wide-ranging practices, including those related to employment, admissions, and compensation. We will cover: Responding to federal agency investigations, which can include CIDs & scope of data production How to prepare for a potential investigation How the proposed IPED revisions may impact reporting burdens How federal agencies may use and share institute data Prospective data analytics that should be conducted
Understanding that everyone is going into Q4, which is the kickoff of your merit and compensation cycles, we want to support those compliance efforts. Join FortneyScott attorneys and our guest speaker, Rick Holt from Resolution Economics, on Thursday, October 23, 2025, at noon EDT for a discussion on strategies for reviewing compensation decisions under the governing legal standards and the Trump Administration’s enforcement priorities. We will focus on discussing: Changes in legal enforcements; Legal considerations for conducting pay analyses; Recommendations on refreshing analysis models; and, Remediation strategies. To register for FortneyScott’s Workplace Legal Compliance training series, please click here .
Federal policies under the Trump Administration are reshaping workplaces nationwide. Employers must stay ahead of evolving laws and shifting EEOC priorities. Join FortneyScott attorneys on Thursday, September 18th at noon EDT to learn the key steps organizations should take now to ensure compliance with EEO laws influenced by these broader policy changes. Key Topics to be Covered Include: Status of the Commission and what to expect once there is a restored quorum; Current EEOC priorities , including protecting religious liberties, eliminating unlawful DEI, and reshaping sex discrimination; Notable EEOC enforcement actions, updates, and emerging trends; and Actionable strategies and key takeaways to ensure compliance with Title VII, the PWFA, etc . This webinar is the first in a four-part series designed for compliance professionals, in-house counsel, HR and inclusion leaders, and other business leaders responsible for labor and employment law compliance.
Federal policies under the Trump Administration are reshaping workplaces nationwide. Employers must stay ahead of evolving laws and shifting EEOC priorities. Join FortneyScott attorneys on Thursday, September 18 th at noon EDT to learn the key steps organizations should take now to ensure compliance with EEO laws influenced by these broader policy changes. Key Topics to be Covered Include: Status of the Commission and what to expect once there is a restored quorum; Current EEOC priorities , including protecting religious liberties, eliminating unlawful DEI, and reshaping sex discrimination; Notable EEOC enforcement actions, updates, and emerging trends; and Actionable strategies and key takeaways to ensure compliance with Title VII, the PWFA, etc. This webinar is the first in a four-part series designed for compliance professionals, in-house counsel, HR and inclusion leaders, and other business leaders responsible for labor and employment law compliance. To register for FortneyScott’s Workplace Legal Compliance training series, please click here .
During the first months of the Trump Administration employers have faced unprecedented challenges in understanding and keeping up with the rapidly changing legal environment. To assist our clients in successfully navigating these challenges, FortneyScott is initiating a four-month, complimentary training program addressing Workplace Legal Compliance. These new, original trainings will occur during September through December, 2025 and will include 4 monthly webinars, at least 4 podcasts of DC Insider—Employer Update and timely alerts as developments unfold. The trainings are designed to provide substantive updates and to assist employers in addressing the latest developments as part of their organization’s comprehensive workplace legal compliance program. How to Participate : Register now for the FortneyScott Workplace Legal Compliance webinars, podcast notifications and alerts: Register for all 4 webinars (September 18, October 23, November 20 and December 18). Register for notifications of new podcast episodes of DC Insider—Employer Update. Register for Workplace Legal Compliance alerts and updates. If you have an immediate questions or feedback, please contact any of the FortneyScott attorneys or email info@fortneyscott.com . Additional Background : Workplace legal compliance is essential for mitigating risk, protecting employees, and fostering a positive and reputable company culture. Adhering to federal, state, and local laws concerning labor, safety, and discrimination prevents costly penalties, lawsuits, and operational disruptions. Beyond simply avoiding legal and financial consequences, compliance builds trust with employees and other stakeholders by demonstrating a commitment to ethical conduct. This creates a fair and safe work environment that boosts employee morale, increases retention, and enhances overall productivity. By proactively managing legal responsibilities, an organization strengthens its reputation and brand image, which in turn can attract top talent and create a competitive advantage in the marketplace. FortneyScott’s Workplace Legal Compliance supports employers in meeting these objectives. Ultimately, legal compliance is not only a regulatory obligation – it is a strategic investment in the long-term success and integrity of your organization.
We are pleased to announce that FortneyScott attorney David Fortney has been recognized as one of The Best Lawyers in America for 2026, in recognition of outstanding achievement and contributions to the field of Labor and Employment law. This marks a continuation of his recognition in The Best Lawyers in America since 2008, reflecting a sustained commitment to excellence, innovation, and leadership. It underscores the impact of his work within the professional community. We extend our congratulations on this well-deserved recognition.
